
It's OK, Stiff, we're confused, too
Like The Wizard of Oz, Pink Floyd: The Wall, or most David Lynch movies, Richard Kelly's Donnie Darko has a reputation among certain viewers for practically begging to be watched while under some influence or another. Kelly's Southland Tales is no different—except that while Donnie Darko
is a fine film regardless of your level of sobriety, the
writer-director's sophomore effort most definitely is not. It's nearly
intolerable, so when the mess comes out on DVD, sooner rather than
later, here are a couple of games to speed oblivion for those who rent
it: For a more intense experience, drink/smoke/drop whenever
"neo-Marxism" is mentioned. Otherwise, simply imbibe whenever a
character puts a gun to his or her head. Unenhanced, you'll sympathize
with such desperation soon enough.
Southland Tales
debuted disastrously at Cannes in 2006, prompting Kelly to trim 19
minutes from what must have been an excruciating 163. He claims to have
streamlined the story, but it's still unwieldy, difficult to
comprehend, and nearly impossible to tidily sum up. Here goes: It's
2008, and a nuclear attack on Texas has set off World War III and
turned the United States into an Orwellian nightmare, with a
comprehensive surveillance program called USIDent instituted by those
pesky Republicans. (One of whom, a politician's wife played by Miranda
Richardson, uses it to assassinate people at her whim.) Access to oil
is a thing of the past, leading a deeply weird man named Baron Von
Westphalen (Wallace Shawn) to invent a perpetual-motion machine that
allows for fuel-free transport (and, apparently, world domination,
though that part's less clear).
Meanwhile,
there's a movie star, Boxer Santaros (Dwayne "the Rock" Johnson), who
disappeared shortly after the attacks and was later found in the desert
with his memory erased. He doesn't remember that he's married to a
presidential candidate's daughter (Mandy Moore), so Boxer takes up with
Krysta Now (Sarah Michelle Gellar), a porn star and talk-show host, and
they write a screenplay about an apocalyptic future that involves a
L'Engle-like tear in the space-time continuum. There are a couple of
war veterans who are mentally fucked after their involvement in a
friendly-fire incident (Justin Timberlake, who also narrates, and Seann
William Scott, who actually plays twins, but that's too nonsensical to
get into). And then there are the neo-Marxists, quite oddly played
predominantly by Saturday Night Live stars such as Amy
Poehler, Cheri Oteri, Jon Lovitz, and Nora Dunn. The gist of it is that
the apocalypse is at hand, and that the world will end, as it's
repeated ad nauseam, "not with a whimper, but with a bang."
The best that can be said about Southland Tales
is that Kelly apparently intended to ramble: The film is divided into
three parts, but it begins with the fourth chapter. (The first three
installments—the "prequel saga," according to the movie's Web site—are
available in graphic-novel form.) Donnie Darko also inspired
companion literature—and was also at times incomprehensible—but its
rabbit holes were controlled, thoughtful, and intriguing; Southland Tales
feels like, to quote one of its characters, the "nervous breakdown of
the century." Its tone is all over the place. One minute, Timberlake is
quoting from Revelation; the next, Gellar offers porn-star wisdom such
as "Scientists are saying the future is going to be far more futuristic
than they originally predicted." The casting of SNL vets exemplifies the film's confusion: It's doomsday. (Even Zelda Rubinstein, Poltergeist's don't-go-into-the-light lady, is here.)
But then you see the comedians and chuckle. But then they start blowing
people's heads off. Kelly's attempt to force humor into the story is so
awkward it quickly becomes as ridiculous as the tangled plot itself.
With
such absurdity, it's futile to analyze the worth of anyone's
performance—one imagines that the Rock was encouraged to do odd, girly
things like tap his fingers together nervously, for example, and that
Gellar actually nailed her character's stiff, dumb-blonde motivation.
One of the better scenes involves a Timberlake musical number. But it's
mostly compelling because it's a friggin' song-and-dance
sequence in the midst of a bunch of Internet feeds and newscasts, and
because he's only lip-syncing…to the Killers' "All These Things That
I've Done," and ultimately it's the great song that gives the movie a
lift. It's a brief respite, but I'll drink to that.

Mr. Retardorium and His Stupid Store
If you've seen the trailers for Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium, you probably noticed it bears a resemblance to Gene Wilder's Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory. Or Johnny Depp's remake, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.
Or, perhaps more accurately, Troy McClure's "The Contrabulous
Fabtraption of Professor Horatio Hufnagel." In other words, this Dustin
Hoffman-led tale of wonderment looked not only like a rip-off but a
pretty bad one at that, and you might have guessed that subtlety was
not going to be one of its strengths.
But
it's rated G, and everyone knows kids are dumb, so maybe they need to
be hit over the head when they go to the movies. The film's promise
lies in its creator, Zach Helm, who makes his directorial debut here
but also wrote 2006's unusual, excellent
Stranger Than Fiction.
No dice: Although the film deals with worthy subjects—death,
appreciating life as a gift, believing in yourself—it too-cutely
glosses over the first while strenuously emphasizing the second and
third. The result, for all its swirly colors and surrealism, is
alternately dull and irritating, an experience akin to learning that
you're going on a field trip only to discover that it's to the box
factory.
Hoffman's performance is,
unsurprisingly, a significant reason the movie fails. As the
243-year-old proprietor of a magical toy store, he affects a lisp and
tight smile to match his wild hair and eyebrows. He's not
childlike—he's childish and dopey, with none of the deliciously dark
weirdness of either Wilder's or Depp's Wonkas. The plot involves
Magorium's "departure": He's choosing to die because he's on his last
pair of a lifetime supply of his favorite shoes. He wants to leave the
store to his manager, Molly Mahoney (Natalie Portman), a piano prodigy
who actually has been wanting to quit because she feels stuck, unable
play like she used to as a kid. The store, a living thing whose toys
animate themselves each morning and whose rooms can be changed with a
dial, doesn't like this plan and rebels by turning its bright walls
gray and having its merchandise malfunction.
In
addition to the always-happy Magorium and self-doubting Mahoney,
there's a humorless accountant (Jason Bateman) and a boy who doesn't
know how to make friends (Zach Mills). Gee, do you think they'll each
learn a lesson by the time the story's through? Yes, a million times
over, and every instance in which the script's life-is-grand message is
repeated is accompanied by the kind of incessantly crescendoing score
that slimes holiday movies. It's not quite terrible; the main
character's demise, however sugar-coated, is touching, Mahoney's
quarter-life crisis is sympathetic, and OK, some of the toys are pretty
cool. But it's never nearly as enchanting as Helm intended, which makes
his foray into children's entertainment an ironic failure.
copyright 2007 letsnotlisten.com